Strike in the sister company
In a new ruling, the Danish Western High Court has determined that a strike in an air carrier's sister company can indeed be considered an extraordinary circumstance beyond the air carrier's control – even if the companies share a common name.
A group of passengers was to travel from Aalborg to Oslo via Copenhagen. Their flight was canceled due to an unlawful strike by ground handling staff, who were employed by a sister company associated with the air carrier, and which had partially the same name as the air carrier. The question was whether the strike could be considered an extraordinary circumstance beyond the air carrier's control that could exempt the air carrier from a compensation claim.
Internal or external
The court concluded that the cancellation was due to external events beyond the air carrier's control. The court emphasized that:
- The strike was unannounced
- The air carrier and the ground handling company had the same parent company but no influence on each other
- The ground handling staff also handled baggage for a number of other air carriers on equal terms with the defendant air carrier
Therefore, the Western High Court found that it was an extraordinary circumstance. The Eastern High Court had previously reached the opposite conclusion in a similar case. The difference was that in this case, sufficient evidence was presented to convince the court that the two companies operated independently of each other – even though they partially shared the same name.
IUNO’s opinion
The case shows that even if an air carrier purchases ground handling services from a sister company, a strike in the sister company should still be considered an external strike if the companies operate independently of each other.
IUNO recommends that air carriers ensure that when they purchase services from affiliated companies, it should be done on an arm's length basis and in such a way that the companies operate independently of each other. If this is adhered to, a strike in a sister company will constitute an extraordinary circumstance. In this way, the air carrier will be exempt from the obligation to pay compensation as a result of the strike.
[The Danish Western High Court's ruling of April 23, 2024, in case BS-31914/2023-VLR]
A group of passengers was to travel from Aalborg to Oslo via Copenhagen. Their flight was canceled due to an unlawful strike by ground handling staff, who were employed by a sister company associated with the air carrier, and which had partially the same name as the air carrier. The question was whether the strike could be considered an extraordinary circumstance beyond the air carrier's control that could exempt the air carrier from a compensation claim.
Internal or external
The court concluded that the cancellation was due to external events beyond the air carrier's control. The court emphasized that:
- The strike was unannounced
- The air carrier and the ground handling company had the same parent company but no influence on each other
- The ground handling staff also handled baggage for a number of other air carriers on equal terms with the defendant air carrier
Therefore, the Western High Court found that it was an extraordinary circumstance. The Eastern High Court had previously reached the opposite conclusion in a similar case. The difference was that in this case, sufficient evidence was presented to convince the court that the two companies operated independently of each other – even though they partially shared the same name.
IUNO’s opinion
The case shows that even if an air carrier purchases ground handling services from a sister company, a strike in the sister company should still be considered an external strike if the companies operate independently of each other.
IUNO recommends that air carriers ensure that when they purchase services from affiliated companies, it should be done on an arm's length basis and in such a way that the companies operate independently of each other. If this is adhered to, a strike in a sister company will constitute an extraordinary circumstance. In this way, the air carrier will be exempt from the obligation to pay compensation as a result of the strike.
[The Danish Western High Court's ruling of April 23, 2024, in case BS-31914/2023-VLR]
Similar
The team
![](/media/22673/siddende_2016.png)
Aage
Krogh
Partner![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Adam
Harding Ryyd Lange
Legal assistant![](/media/29528/amalie_siddende_2023.png)
Amalie
Bjerre Hilmand
Legal advisor![](/media/23704/amalie_siddende_2023.png)
Amalie
Sofie Sveen Kvam
Legal assistant![](/media/29532/amanda_siddende_2023.png)
Amanda
Jepsen Bregnhardt
Senior legal assistant![](/media/29499/andrea_siddende_2023.png)
Andrea
Brix Danielsen
Legal advisor![](/media/23097/anna_siddende_2023.png)
Anna
Bonander
Legal advisor![](/media/25910/anna_siddende_2023.png)
Anna
Kreutzmann
Senior legal assistant![](/media/23359/anne_siddende_2023.png)
Anne
Voigt Kjær
Junior legal advisor![](/media/23052/anton_siddende_2023.png)
Anton
Winther Hansen
Legal advisor![](/media/29503/ashley_siddende_2023.png)
Ashley
Kristine Morton
Legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Benedicte
Rodian
Senior legal assistant![](/media/17880/bror_siddende_2021.png)
Bror
Johan Kristensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Chanel
Adzioski
Junior legal assistant![](/media/15171/chris_siddende_2020.png)
Chris
Anders Nielsen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/29536/cille_siddende_2023.png)
Cille
Fahnø
Junior legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Clara
Caballero Stephensen
Junior legal advisor![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Daniel
Bornhøft Nielsen
Junior legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Ellen
Priess-Hansen
Senior legal assistant![](/media/22203/elvira_siddende_2022.png)
Elvira
Feline Basse Schougaard
Senior legal advisor![](/media/29540/ema_siddende_2023.png)
Ema
Besic-Ahmetagic
Legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Emilia
Naledi Madonsela Mikkelsen
Junior legal assistant![](/media/29565/emma_siddende_2023.png)
Emma
Engvang Hansen
Senior legal assistant![](/media/17930/emma_siddende_2021.png)
Emma
Frøslev Larsen
Legal manager![](/media/20082/fransine_siddende_2022.png)
Fransine
Andersson
Legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Frederikke
Kirkegaard Thalund
Legal assistant![](/media/23367/frederikke_siddende_2023.png)
Frederikke
Østerlund Haarder
Junior legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Frida
Aas Ahlquist
Legal assistant![](/media/21173/frida_siddende_2022.png)
Frida
Assarson
Senior legal advisor![](/media/25960/gustav_siddende_2023.png)
Gustav
Vestergaard
Senior legal assistant![](/media/30441/hanna_siddende_2024.png)
Hanna
Honerød Augestad
Junior legal advisor![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Holger
Koch-Klarskov
Junior legal assistant![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Ian
Englev Jensen
Junior legal assistant![](/media/23066/isabella_siddende_2023.png)
Isabella
Rocio Nielsen
Legal advisor![](/media/23069/izabell_siddende_2023.png)
Izabell
Celina Bastrup Lüthje
Senior legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Jacqueline
Lucia Chrillesen
Junior legal assistant![](/media/25970/johanne_siddende_2023.png)
Johanne
Berner Nielsen
Senior legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Julia
Wolfe
Legal advisor![](/media/29625/kaisa_siddende_2023.png)
Kaisa
Nova Ordell Guldbrand Thygaard
Legal advisor![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Karl Emil
Tang Nielsen
Legal assistant![](/media/29629/karoline_siddende_2023.png)
Karoline
Halfdan Petersen
Legal manager![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Karoline
Nordved
Legal assistant![](/media/29637/laura_siddende_2023.png)
Laura
Jørgensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/1973/siddende_sort.png)
Mathias
Bech Linaa
Junior legal advisor![](/media/15730/maya_siddende_2020.png)
Maya
Cecillia Jørgensen
Senior legal advisor![](/media/22237/mie_siddende_2022.png)
Mie
Lundberg Larsen
Junior legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Nanna
Damkjær
Junior legal assistant![](/media/23526/rosa_siddende_2023.png)
Rosa
Gilliam-Vigh
Legal advisor![](/media/24684/selma_siddende_2023.png)
Selma
Agopian
Senior EU associate![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Selma
Klinker Brodersen
Junior legal advisor![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Silja
Brünnich Fogh von Deden
Junior legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Silje
Moen Knutsen
Legal advisor![](/media/29653/sille_siddende_2023.png)
Sille
Lyng Mejding
Legal advisor![](/media/26084/stine_siddende_2023.png)
Stine
Bank Olstrøm
Senior legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)
Ulrikke
Sejersbøl Christiansen
Legal assistant![](/media/1978/siddende_pige.png)